No response from YAT after sending command

Kayjay

@dc42 Thanks David, that's actually confirmed that I understood how it worked apart from how to enable DHCP, which again is actually what I thought it was. So here is my problem still -

I enter 0.0.0.0 into config.g instead of the real IP address, I then try to connect but the browser just times out. Would this be a problem with my router, perhaps that isn't set for DHCP. I'll check out the admin page on my router, in the meantime could you give me your thoughts on my thoughts

Keith

Phaedrux

@kayjay said in No response from YAT after sending command:

I then try to connect

What are you trying to connect to though?

dc42

@kayjay said in No response from YAT after sending command:

I then try to connect but the browser just times out.

What IP address did you enter in the browser, and where did you get that IP address from?

Kayjay

@phaedrux The duet web control. It works fine if I have 192.168.1.14 in config.g and I enter that in the browser, all is ok but I wanted to change it over so that DHCP is in control of the IP.

Kayjay

@dc42 I entered 192.168.1.14 and I got it from YAT when I connected to the board with USB during initial setting up, I had the board on my desk next to my PC. Now I can't connect via USB coz the printer is in a different room to my PC.

dc42

@kayjay said in No response from YAT after sending command:

@dc42 I entered 192.168.1.14 and I got it from YAT when I connected to the board with USB during initial setting up, I had the board on my desk next to my PC. Now I can't connect via USB coz the printer is in a different room to my PC.

Like I said, your router will almost certain allocate a different IP address via DHCP.

Kayjay

@dc42 I undestand that, perhaps I'm missing something somewhere. I put 0.0.0.0 into config.g for the IP address to enable DHCP. Isn't the s/w and the router supposed to take over now with no more input from me? so the IP is irrelevant, to me it's invisible when DHCP is working correctly. I'm only entering 192.168.1.14 to get a connection manually because DHCP won't do it, the browser just times out.

I'll check through the router settings again in case I don't have DHCP activated in there.

Keith

Phaedrux

@kayjay said in No response from YAT after sending command:

so the IP is irrelevant,

The IP is still very much relevant. DHCP will have assigned a new IP to the Duet. You will still need to know what it is to connect to it. And the router will need to be configured to reserve that new IP address for the Duet, otherwise it may change again in the future if the lease expires and isn't renewed. (for example, if the duet is left powered off for a while.)

In your case, if you can't arrange a DHCP reservation, it may be best to specify a static IP for the Duet using an IP either outside the DCHP range while still in the same subnet, or in the upper end of the DCHP range to hopefully avoid a potential conflict in the future where the router assigns the same IP you are using.

Kayjay

@phaedrux Sorry, I didn't mean that the IP wasn't relevant at all, I just meant it wasn't relevant when in DHCP because I don't need to enter it. Isn't DHCP supposed to do all that and make it invisible to me?

Your other suggestion sounds a better option for me, as you say making sure the IP is away from the ones that may be possible used by DHCP, I'll try that.

Incidentally, my router admin pages reports the IP for Duettest as 192.168.1.95 but if I enter that into the browser it times out. I can still connct successfully with 192.168.1.14. I can control the printer on that IP, turn heaters on and off, move motors etc etc...... wierd or what !

Keith

Phaedrux

@kayjay said in No response from YAT after sending command:

sn't DHCP supposed to do all that and make it invisible to me?

Only if you're using a mDNS name to access the IP, like http://duet.local which I don't think works with the Duet Ethernet

Kayjay

@phaedrux OK, I think you're right there.

So, let me see if I have this right. I enable DHCP in config.g by creating a line that says

M552 P0.0.0.0

then I discover the IP either through my router or YAT, I the enter that IP into the browser address bar and it should stay the same all the time. Is that how DHCP works when done properly?

Keith

Phaedrux

@kayjay said in No response from YAT after sending command:

Is that how DHCP works when done properly?

Yes, provided there is a DHCP reservation in the router for that IP, it should stay the same.

Kayjay

@phaedrux OK, thanks ...... phew I got there at last I'll play about with it now and if I still can't achieve connection I'll set it up the way you suggested earlier.

Thanks pal ! you're a star .... and you too David !

Kayjay

@phaedrux Should the Gateway be set to 0 with M554 P0.0.0.0 as well ?

Phaedrux

I think the gateway would still be your router IP

dc42

If you are using DHCP to get the IP address then it will automatically get the gateway address that way too.

Kayjay

@dc42 ok now I am puzzled. The config.g commenting says make the next two lines 0 for DHCP, which is the IP M552 and Gateway M554, so which is right. What should I enter in Gateway? I currently have 0.0.0.0 and it's connecting.

Phaedrux

My response was just based on the notes from the gcode wiki for setting the gateway. Go with DC42s response. which I think means that regardless of what you specify for the gateway in config.g if your IP address is set to 0.0.0.0 to get a DHCP address, the gateway will also be set via DHCP, so you don't have to worry bout it.

Kayjay

@phaedrux

Yep, se what you mean. OK, as I have it at 0 now I'll leave that and let the DHCP sort it out.