U-axis without limit

tntjet

The question is how ? im currently on 3.2.

Phaedrux

@tntjet If only there were a list of changes.... Oh wait

https://github.com/Duet3D/RepRapFirmware/blob/v3-dev/WHATS_NEW_RRF3.md

New features/changed behaviour:

When new axes are created using M584, if no R parameter is specified then the default for axes ABCD is now rotational. Use the R0 parameter if you want them to be linear.
M584 has a new S parameter which specifies whether new axes created in the command are to be treated as linear (S0) or rotational (S1) for the purpose of feedrate calculation. This is separate from the R parameter, which specifies whether new axes are rotational or not. The default is to treat linear axes as linear and rotational axes as rotational. You only need to provide the S parameter if you want to change the way that the feed rate is applied.

Does that make sense? I'm not a CNC user.

tntjet

@phaedrux, im not looking at having an argument i have read the change log over and over as well as the dozuki info , the issue im having is my axis is named U (it works with the pendant this way) changelog spesifies A,B,C,D.

Exerp from dozuki

M584: Set drive mapping
Parameters

Xnnn Driver number(s) for X motor(s)
Ynnn Driver number(s) for Y motor(s)
Znnn Driver number(s) for Z motor(s)
Rn (optional, supported in RRF 3.2beta1 and later) 0 = axes creates in this command are linear, 1 = axes created are rotational. If not present, then RRF 3.2beta3 and later assume UVW are linear and ABCD are rotational.
Sn (optional, supported in RRF 3.2beta3 and later) 0 = axes created in this command are treated as linear in feedrate calculations, 1 = axes created are treated as rotational in feedrate calculations. See section 2.1.2.5 of the NIST GCode standard for how the feedrate is interpreted. Default is S0 for linear axes and S1 for rotational axes (see the R parameter).
U, V, W, A, B, Cnnn Driver number(s) for additional axes U, V, W, A, B and C (UVW available in RepRapFirmware 1.16 and later; UVWABC available in RepRapFirmware 1.19 and later; UVWABCD available in RepRapFirmware 3.0 and later).
Ennn Driver number(s) for E motor(s)
Pnnn Number of visible axes, defaults to the total number of axes configured.

im looking for an unlimited rotational axis . as far as i understand Im required to compile my own firmware to make this happen , I am not capable of compiling firmware can anybody help?

Phaedrux

Sorry was just trying to be funny not have an argument. Was just trying to help.

Phaedrux

@tntjet said in U-axis without limit:

im looking for an unlimited rotational axis . as far as i understand Im required to compile my own firmware to make this happen , I am not capable of compiling firmware can anybody help?

I don't know why you assume that. You could install 3.2 beta 4 right now if you wanted to test with it.

@tntjet said in U-axis without limit:

the issue im having is my axis is named U (it works with the pendant this way) changelog spesifies A,B,C,D.

From my reading of the changelog, yes I think you would have to use ABCD for a rotational axis. How does it conflict with the pendant?

tntjet

@Phadrux The pendant only recognises the axis if it is named U. A,B,C or D wont work

Phaedrux

@tntjet Do you have a link to the pendant?

tntjet

@Phaedrux

https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/11389/cnc-style-pendant/2?_=1607728006898

cpirius

I'm having trouble with this as well for an openpnp machine. Trying to move from using an "extruder" to a rotary axis for part rotation. But whether I define:

M584 X0 Y2 Z1 A3

or

M584 X0 Y2 Z1
M584 U3 R1

or

M584 X0 Y2 Z1
M584 A3

My rotary axis, either A or U, still only lets me move from 0 - 200 position. There is no infinite rotation.

Is there something beyond configuring the axis as a rotation axis to remove the limits?

Thanks

Stephen6309

@cpirius AFAIK, you have to define it as an extruder. Extruders have no limits on distance.

tntjet

@Stephen6309 they certainly do have unlimited rotation , unfortunately not helpful for cnc applications nor using a pendant.

dc42

I have added this to my list to look into for RRF 3.3.

tntjet

@dc42 thank you David.

cpirius

@dc42 Awesome, thanks

RandyL00123

@wuem said in U-axis without limit:

imit. Ev

https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Gcode#Section_M584_Set_drive_mapping
Rn allows you to set an axis as rotational. Like printing on a pot can maybe?

rry

Hi David. Thank your for good job!

Can someone did continues rotation?
I expect something like this:
M584 X1 R1; set X axis as continues rotational
//on working program
G1 X F100 ; rotate X continuesly with speed 100 or best way to use some new M code for rotation
G1 Y10 F200;
...
G1 X F300; after Y moved to 10 and some other things rotate X with speed 300
G1 Y-10 F200;
G1 X F0; after Y moved to -10 stop X rotation

or may be somebody can suggest working solution, then I need continues rotation on pulling tape or similar.
One solution I see to use analog output connected to external drive with analog speed control like Spindle.
Thank you

o_lampe

@rry
I guess for combined XY moves you have to define an angle for X, not just a speed.
EG. positive angle = clockwise, neg. angle = CCW

G1 X1000 Y10 F100 ; turn X axis 10 times (100rad = 1 turn) while moving Y 10mm

rry

@o_lampe
Yes, you are right, my g-code is wrong, i only tried to show idea that for continues rotation distance does not matter, you need only speed and direction.
seem the most correct way will use new M code for that purpose for example:
Mxxx Xnnn; start to rotate axis X with speed xxx (non blocking command!)
Mxxx A-600; rotate axis A (setup A as continuesly rotation in config) with speed 600 counter-clockwise