Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer

wouldstain

@dc42 attached as requested.

A Former User

@dc42 said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@wouldstain @TheDragonLord please also provide your config.g files, to help us reproduce this.

If it could help I've discovered that the Magnetic sensor "doesn't like" theese two Ideamaker settings (that's the slicer I use). Unchecking both of them the false errors reduces a lot but, of course, this can't be the solution because in this way you get bad prints....

T3P3Tony

@thedragonlord I have been working on replicating the very fast error print you sent through

Please can you send through the two macros that are called by your start gcode:

M98 P"Print_gcodes/print_petg_pressure_advance.g" ;pressure advance
M98 P"Print_gcodes/print_start_gcode.g" ; start gcode operations

I get not "great" results but not nothing like as wide a variation as you see

measured sensitivity 24.45mm/rev, min 70% max 103% over 219.2mm
measured sensitivity 24.53mm/rev, min 71% max 103% over 140.2mm
measured sensitivity 24.64mm/rev, min 71% max 104% over 100.9mm
measured sensitivity 24.89mm/rev, min 72% max 104% over 61.5mm

as an aside, you may have already resolved this but this is an error in your config.g (its not related to this issue):

M350 E16:E16 I0

The second E should not be there

T3P3Tony

@thedragonlord said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

If it could help I've discovered that the Magnetic sensor "doesn't like" theese two Ideamaker settings (that's the slicer I use). Unchecking both of them the false errors reduces a lot but, of course, this can't be the solution because in this way you get bad prints....

Yes, these settings probably cause a lot of short moves with retraction which may be related to the issue.

A Former User

@t3p3tony said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@thedragonlord I have been working on replicating the very fast error print you sent through

Please can you send through the two macros that are called by your start gcode:
M98 P"Print_gcodes/print_petg_pressure_advance.g" ;pressure advance
M98 P"Print_gcodes/print_start_gcode.g" ; start gcode operations
I get not "great" results but not nothing like as wide a variation as you see

measured sensitivity 24.45mm/rev, min 70% max 103% over 219.2mm
measured sensitivity 24.53mm/rev, min 71% max 103% over 140.2mm
measured sensitivity 24.64mm/rev, min 71% max 104% over 100.9mm
measured sensitivity 24.89mm/rev, min 72% max 104% over 61.5mm

as an aside, you may have already resolved this but this is an error in your config.g (its not related to this issue):

M350 E16:E16 I0

The second E should not be there

Here are the g files and thanks for the M350!
print_petg_pressure_advance.g.txt
print_start_gcode.g.txt

T3P3Tony

@thedragonlord thanks, sorry to be a pain but can I also have your heightmap.csv file.

basically looking for anything at impacts the print process.

A Former User

@t3p3tony said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@thedragonlord thanks, sorry to be a pain but can I also have your heightmap.csv file.

basically looking for anything at impacts the print process.

You don't need to apolgize, you are helping me so it's all ok!

Here's the file:

heightmap.csv

A Former User

@t3p3tony said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@thedragonlord thanks, sorry to be a pain but can I also have your heightmap.csv file.

basically looking for anything at impacts the print process.

have you discovered something? The sensor are almost completely unuseful because they keep om pausing even without the two settings...

EDIT:
I was thinking about a thing....could it be that this issue depends from the pressure advance? I'm using it with 0.4 value...

T3P3Tony

@thedragonlord I managed to get some testing done this week and have passed the results on to @dc42. I have some more tests to do though. I made a cut down version of your print file, with as little movement as possible to see some of the effect and got 64% to 106% which for movement with no major retractions I find odd. So in summary its not forgotten, but not pinned down yet.

CNCModeller

@t3p3tony said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@thedragonlord I managed to get some testing done this week and have passed the results on to @dc42. I have some more tests to do though. I made a cut down version of your print file, with as little movement as possible to see some of the effect and got 64% to 106% which for movement with no major retractions I find odd. So in summary its not forgotten, but not pinned down yet.

I've also been seeing some unusual behaviour with my 600ppr encoder based filament sensor but didn't have time to investigate so I've disabled it for now.

If there is any significant updates on this I'll reactivate my DIY sensor.

A Former User

@t3p3tony said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@thedragonlord I managed to get some testing done this week and have passed the results on to @dc42. I have some more tests to do though. I made a cut down version of your print file, with as little movement as possible to see some of the effect and got 64% to 106% which for movement with no major retractions I find odd. So in summary its not forgotten, but not pinned down yet.

ok, thanks! I think the key is PA...Let me know

dc42

@thedragonlord I have been testing magnetic filament monitor reporting yesterday and today with a view to discovering why some users are experiencing this type of problem. As part of this I am putting together a set of test files. Here are the first three (more will follow). Please try them on your machine. In each case:

Select a tool and preheat it to your normal extrusion temperature, or a little higher (to make sure the extruder doesn't skip steps)
Ensure that the MFM is disabled (use M591 D0 S0 if you are testing extruder 0)
Run the file. It will home the printer if it hasn't already been homed, then extrude 10mm above the bed between X0 Y0 and X0 Y50. So it should be OK to run on almost any printer.
At the end it will use M591 to report the calibration data. Report the results here.
For the third one, the results may depend on your pressure advance setting. I get good results with PA=0.2 (my usual setting) and also with PA=1 but your results may vary.
The default extrusion speed is 1mm/sec. You can run the tests at a higher extrusion speed using the speed multiplier or the extrusion factor multiplier.

MFM test 3.gcode MFM test 2.gcode MFM test 1.gcode

A Former User

@dc42 said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@thedragonlord I have been testing magnetic filament monitor reporting yesterday and today with a view to discovering why some users are experiencing this type of problem. As part of this I am putting together a set of test files. Here are the first three (more will follow). Please try them on your machine. In each case:

Select a tool and preheat it to your normal extrusion temperature, or a little higher (to make sure the extruder doesn't skip steps)

Ensure that the MFM is disabled (use M591 D0 S0 if you are testing extruder 0)

Run the file. It will home the printer if it hasn't already been homed, then extrude 10mm above the bed between X0 Y0 and X0 Y50. So it should be OK to run on almost any printer.

At the end it will use M591 to report the calibration data. Report the results here.

For the third one, the results may depend on your pressure advance setting. I get good results with PA=0.2 (my usual setting) and also with PA=1 but your results may vary.

The default extrusion speed is 1mm/sec. You can run the tests at a higher extrusion speed using the speed multiplier or the extrusion factor multiplier.

MFM test 3.gcode MFM test 2.gcode MFM test 1.gcode

Thanks! I'll try the three files when I'll be back home this evening and I'll let tyou know

dc42

@thedragonlord here's test file 4. For this one you need to configure firmware retraction using M207.

MFM test 4.gcode

dc42

@wouldstain please can you run these four test files too.

A Former User

@dc42 said in Rotating Magnetic Sensor - Keeps Pausing Printer:

@thedragonlord here's test file 4. For this one you need to configure firmware retraction using M207.

MFM test 4.gcode

I'll try this too. I've never used the M207, I suppose I have to configure it with the same params I set in the slicer for retraction, right? I usually set 3mm at 40mm/sec so I have to set:

M207 P0 S3 F2400

and set it in the config.g correct?

T3P3Tony

@thedragonlord yes thats right

alankilian

Here are my results if they are helpful:
FIRMWARE_NAME: RepRapFirmware for Duet 2 WiFi/Ethernet FIRMWARE_VERSION: 3.2 ELECTRONICS: Duet Ethernet 1.02 or later FIRMWARE_DATE: 2021-01-05

(I took out the var... part since my version of RRF doesn't support that)

Duet3D rotating magnet filament monitor v3 on pin e0stop, enabled, sensitivity 28.80mm/rev, allow 60% to 160%, check every 3.0mm, version 3, mag 132 agc 114, measured sensitivity 26.00mm/rev, min 98% max 102% over 98.5mm
Finished printing file 0:/gcodes/1635171097795-mfm-test-1.gcode, print time was 0h 0m

Duet3D rotating magnet filament monitor v3 on pin e0stop, enabled, sensitivity 28.80mm/rev, allow 60% to 160%, check every 3.0mm, version 3, mag 132 agc 114, measured sensitivity 26.40mm/rev, min 96% max 103% over 98.8mm
Finished printing file 0:/gcodes/1635171097802-mfm-test-2.gcode, print time was 0h 0m

Duet3D rotating magnet filament monitor v3 on pin e0stop, enabled, sensitivity 28.80mm/rev, allow 60% to 160%, check every 3.0mm, version 3, mag 131 agc 114, measured sensitivity 26.76mm/rev, min 97% max 102% over 48.5mm
Finished printing file 0:/gcodes/1635171097805-mfm-test-3.gcode, print time was 0h 0m

(At this point, I entered M207 P0 S3 F2400 in the GCODE console)
Duet3D rotating magnet filament monitor v3 on pin e0stop, enabled, sensitivity 28.80mm/rev, allow 60% to 160%, check every 3.0mm, version 3, mag 131 agc 114, measured sensitivity 26.80mm/rev, min 96% max 103% over 40.0mm
Finished printing file 0:/gcodes/1635173702760-mfm-test-4.gcode, print time was 0h 0m

dc42

PS all these files use relative extrusion. I will add M83 commands to the final versions, in the mean time feel free to ad M83 commands yourself if you do not have M83 in config.g.

dc42

@alankilian thanks, so far they look good (I'm looking at the measured sensitivity min/max). More test files to follow.