Retraction... once more with FEELING!
-
The fact that there is no difference apparent between settings suggests to me that retraction isn't happening, per @bot's suggestion. If you put a mark on the filament, can you see it jumping up during retractions?
-
I'm not familiar with nylon, but with other materials (PLA, PETG, ABS) I've found turning OFF a part cooling fan can reduce very thin stringing.
-
Something else to try...
Disclaimer: While I state it several times below, this post is based my beliefs mixed with facts. I'm not the kind of engineer that understands the "why" of stringing, and I don't want to represent myself as someone who actually knows what they're talking about in that regard...
Similar to typical configurations of remote direct drive extruders (such as the flex3drive and nimble), the "jerk" is pretty low at only 300mm/min (or 5mm/sec.) In the case of the remote extruders, they suggest a value as slow as 50 (but I'm using 250 on my nimble.)
I believe (without proof or any factual knowledge) that these very slow jerk settings make retraction less useful: If the extruder is extruding filament out at 1mm/sec and you retract at 60mm/sec (as per your m207), you're requesting an speed change of 61mm/sec - which is greater than the max of 5mm/sec specified in the M566 configuration.
While I won't pretend to know exactly how RRF handles this situation, it suggests that a retraction actually causes the nozzle to pause in place for some amount of time in order to "instantly" switch from +1mm/sec to -4mm/sec and then accelerate to a max of 60mm/sec (at a rate of 660mm/sec per sec) until it's retracted the set amount of filament. I don't know the exact amount of time that it would take to retract 2mm with a max of 60mm/sec with those values, but however long it takes is time that the nozzle is just sitting there against the most recently deposited filament, as well as oozing a bit, creating a recipe for stringing.
(Compare that with a direct drive extruder, such as a titan aero, where the jerk can easily be set as high as 3600 - which allows the extruder to go from 1mm/sec extruding to 59mm/sec retraction instantly.)
With all that typed (and hopefully it's accurate), the idea is that the configured values for E's accel and jerk don't allow QUICK retractions, which I suspect reduces the effectiveness of them.
Can you tinker with the jerk (M566) and accel (M201) to try and make them faster? I don't know how much abuse the orbiter's LDO stepper can take, nor the amount of abuse the gears in the orbiter can handle.
However, you can (at your own risk) tinker with the settings by printing your retraction test with retractions set to 2mm all the way through, and then modify the M566 E value (during the print from the DWC console) until the extruder starts skipping steps (clicking) or making unusual noises. While testing, also watch the filament feeding into the extruder to make sure it's actually retracting when it should.
Once you've reached your highest jerk, back it off a bit. Then start tinkering with the acceleration (M201) to raise it using the same method.
Are you able to reach higher values? Does it help?
-
I finally got my "boring work" done, so I've got time to run more tests. While I'm doing that, I'll answer some of the excellent suggestions that were contributed:
@oliof Thank you for suggesting Michael Hackney's blog posts, they've been very enlightening. He's more wordy than I am (which is saying something), but he has some good wisdom in there and I now have a much better understanding of how retractions (and a great many other things) work
@bot Yes it's direct drive. I've confirmed that the very short 34mm bowden tube is in fact tightly secured at all times and not bending or shifting in any direction, either while extruding or retracting. And yes, the set screws on the hobs are very tight. There doesn't appear to be any sloppiness in the filament movement from my inspection.
@whopping-pochard I just checked, and the filament is in fact moving during retraction. I can feel it with my hand while manually issuing G10/G11 commands, and the different retraction lengths are definitely having an effect. It's fairly easy to tell a difference between 0.4mm and 2.0mm of retraction.
@garyd9 For nylon, the part cooling fan is typically left off altogether except for bridging and such. I've been running all tests with it off. The Orbiter extruder I'm using is not remote direct drive, it has the motor right on the extruder. It is geared down like a remote direct drive extruder, but not as much. The Flex3Drive I used to run was geared at 40:1, the Orbitter I'm using now is about 7:1. You're totally right that these slow jerk settings tend to cause the nozzle to sit in one place for a bit wile the retraction is happening. That's probably a big part of what's happening here. Espeially with nylon at high temperature, which tends to get really runny and stringy. As long as the nozzle is moving fast, everything is great. But as soon as it pauses, the oozing happens. Unfortunately there's only so much jerk that de-geared extruders can manage, specifically because of that gearing. It's interesting that you mention the Titan extruder (3:1) can be set as high as 3600. That implies that my extruder (7:1) should be able to handle up to 1550, though the tiny Nema 14 motor I'm using may not be able to achieve that like a Nema 17 motor can. I'll try it out and see what kind of difference it makes
-
@whopping-pochard I just checked, and the filament is in fact moving during retraction. I can feel it with my hand while manually issuing G10/G11 commands, and the different retraction lengths are definitely having an effect. It's fairly easy to tell a difference between 0.4mm and 2.0mm of retraction.
Take it a step further and make sure it is happening during a test print.
-
I think I nailed it:
(note: the bottom is wavy because it's only 0.5mm thick and I just peeled it off the hot bed)
Ultimately, the solution was to minimize the amount of time that the nozzle stays in one place, and reduce the possibility of it moving across gaps immediately from the edge of a wall. I upped the speed (3600mm/s), acceleration (1500mm/s2) and jerk (1200mm/min) settings for the extruder, shortened the extrusion distance (1mm), fixed the "combing" setting in Cura (changed to "not in skin"), randomized the Z seam, and upped the outer wall wipe distance from 0.2mm to 0.4mm. Now all the stringing is gone. I still get some scarring on top skin from drooping filament, but it's minimal and literally the only minor blemish. Everything else prints so well, you'd think it was molded. Even tiny details that I used to struggle with now come out crisp and sharp.
Thanks all for the advice!
-
@goremanx What that 3600mm/sec or 3600mm/min?
-
@gorillamotors it's probably per minute since I can't imagine my extruder spitting out 10+ feet of filament per second
-
@goremanx said in Retraction... once more with FEELING!:
I've got pressure advance set to:
M572 D0 S0.03Though I've tried every value from 0 to 1.0. Results were much worse the closer I got to 1.0. The 0.03 value is the recommendation for this extruder.
As you have a 34mm Bowden tube between the extruder and the hot end, a higher value is almost certainly optimal. I would expect the optimum to be less than 0.1.
I've never printed nylon, but when printing PLA I found the best way to avoid stringing was to reduce print temperature - although that was before we had pressure advance..
-
I think the oozing is caused by the hotend staying too much on the place during retraction. If your printed is well calibrated and creates no irregular surfaces, i would set Z hop to 0mm for retraction and crank up the retraction speed and acceleration. With my direct extruder i use 0.03PA and 0.75mm retraction at 60mm/s and deretraction at 40mm/s.
Obviously the problem is higher with high flow hotends. That is why i would only use them if really needed. -
Ok so everyone realizes that this thread was solved months ago, right ?
-
@goremanx They must just be hooked on the feeling.
