Unable to print PLA
-
@deckingman I did not run an airtest as you suggested as it seems to extrude freely when the build plate is nowhere near the hot end, even at slow feed rates.
I looked at the mosquito and the pricetag and realized that for that amount of money I could get another E3D plus extruder and all the trimmings and set up a dual system so... I've sort of ruled that out for the time being as just too expensive.
I MAY have identified the problem. It's looking like its something VERY small having a very big impact.
Running more tests and will report back with results.
-
@theruttmeister been replacing parts one at a time... slow going.
same thing for changing settings.... one at a time. print.. see what happens...filament has minimal deformation aside from teeth marks from the drive gear.
-
Possible solve...
I may be speaking too early on this but it's looking promising.I've been super focused on what could cause the filament to start a phase transition
in the wrong location and I THINK I've got it.The short of it is that the PTFE tube connecting the extruder to the hotend may have been a hair or two short of seating solidly against the heatbreak.
Long version...
The way this probably came about is, because the PTFE collet on the bottom of the extruder is not visible from above (I have a Railcore 300ZLT so it's pretty tall and sits on the floor), I'd gotten in the habit of leaving the collet on the extruder and removing the one on the heatsink coupler and just pulling the extruder and tube out in a single step. When reassembling the extruder after cleaning it, I probably seated the tubing as far into the extruder as I could, leaving a small gap between the heat break and PTFE tube. Clearly I must have cut the tube a bit short.This was literally the only thing I could of, so I tried re-seating the tube all the way down inside the heatsink, reassembling everything, and I'm suddenly able to complete a test cube out of PLA.
Going to run a few more tests before I call this one resolved but this sort of fits what I've been seeing and is consistent with your advice about what could cause this.
-
@wouldstain thanks for the update. how has it progressed?
-
@t3p3tony It's looking like the PTFE tube was in fact the issue. I've successfully printed out a few items in PLA now with zero stops. I've also dialed back the MFM parameters so it's no longer wide open and still no problems.
I have to pull the tube out and measure it to see just how short it was (build docs call for 91mm) but the only things I can attribute this to is my being a creature of habit. I've pulled that tube many times while yanking the extruder for cleaning and repeated the same error by installing it in the extruder first.
I'd say mark this one as resolved but I'm going to run some longer prints in PLA just to be 100% as there was an element of randomness to it.
Props to @deckingman for getting me focused on the right thing and thanks to everyone who responded!
-
@wouldstain Sounds like you've got it sorted. PLA can be temperamental and prone to blockages in and around the heat break area due to it's very low Tg.
TIP - always use Bowden clips at the hot end to prevent the PTFE liner being pushed up. If you start printing with highish melt rates, the back pressure can dislodge the PTFE liner resulting in the gap that you've seen. I generally exert pressure on the tube to keep it seated while lifting the ring on the Bowden fitting and then slide in the clip. In my case, the extruders are mounted on a separate gantry above the hot end, and I cut the Bowden tubes slightly long so that they are always under compression (but I still use clips as well).
-
@T3P3Tony
Sadly, I thought this was resolved. I did manage to get a few small prints out of this, however it has started happening again.I reached out to E3D support and they have me messing around with print speed and temp settings. As part of this exercise, I returned the hotend to its original configuration, which included switching out the nozzle.
I ran the PID tuning routine (going from brass to tool steel) for the hotend and it stopped on phase 3 and allowed the temp to return to ambient with no console output over a period of about 30 minutes. This happened twice before I was finally able to get a result.
Is it possible there is something wrong with my Duet board or firmware?
I'm still running 3.4b5+1. -
@wouldstain said in Unable to print PLA:
Is it possible there is something wrong with my Duet board or firmware?
I'm still running 3.4b5+1.Either try 3.3 or 3.4b7
-
@phaedrux installed 3.4b7+3 and I've had two consecutive successful prints of a file with no stops! crossing fingers....
just read b7 notes and it looks like PID tuning got some love!
thank you!
-
@phaedrux sadly failed on the third try.
-
@wouldstain said in Unable to print PLA:
@phaedrux sadly failed on the third try.
I've got five different printers running 3.3 on Duet 2 and Duet 3 hardware.
They all work fine.
Try 3.3
Frederick
-
@fcwilt had same issue w/ 3.3
-
@wouldstain Have you done the obvious thing and checked the previous cause? You said before that the PTFE liner wasn't correctly seated and when you rectified that, it cured the problem.
-
@deckingman First thing I checked!
-
@wouldstain If you can still print other filament types, then it rules out anything related to Duet hardware or firmware and has to be related to PLA swelling and blocking the heat break area of the hot end. I refer you back to the first post I made on 14th November.
