Hollow shaft extruder
-
@o_lampe said in Hollow shaft extruder:
That's about 2065 steps/mm for a regular stepper setup.
Rq3 who first pioneered the VDE-100 says he once completed a 5nm layer height print. Apparently it took a very long time but came out very smooth.
-
@zero-K As @o_lampe says, this is a much heavier stepper than needed. However it should do the job even with a 12V PSU. It will need something like 500mA to accelerate really well, by which I mean 1000mm/s^2 E feed acceleration.
I have a script that generates speed vs acceleration graphs for steppers. I'll try to post it at some point along with an explanation.
-
@breed 3mm filament takes longer to melt all the way through, and everyone wants to push print speeds faster and faster. 3mm filament is much stiffer than 1.75 so you need bigger, heavier motors to move it for most extruder designs.
I suspect we'll end up with 1mm dia filament in the not too distant future to allow the hot end to keep up with the rest of the mechanism.
-
Hi, its my first printer building myself - my first was a kit to assemble
My actuel dual print head is about 1100 g.If this new one is not as optimized in wight as yours, it´s not the end of the world for me.
Its a very nice project, I like the way filament ist moved and i can watch someting turning around and moving
It´s quite possible, if it works a little bit more as (with my skills) expected I will try to get 99%.Thank you
zero K -
@mrehorstdmd That's interesting. I wonder where the 1.75mm came from? I'm assuming 3mm was plastic welding wire originally.
-
A way to increase the filament heating surface sems to be Bondtech/MicroSwiss CTH-Nozzle und e3D high speed Revo.
No one of my friend is printing 3 mm Filament - this time has gone. -
@breed around 40grams, but it has only 1/10th of the holding torque as Tom already mentioned. It could become interesting for thinner filament or with a planetary gear
-
@zero-K It pushes the point where unmelted filament starts to clog the nozzle to a higher speed. Below that speed my experience with a CHT clone is that it actually increases back-pressure. This is not surprising because increased surface area should be expected to cause increased drag. And with the clone CHTs there is a big flat face in the middle of the 3 holes that almost blocks filament flow. Until you file it away, that is.
-
I have a moment to give the long answer now: the bearings cut a spiral groove around the filament.
Imagine that groove as a line on a thin straw shape 1.75mm in diameter. If you split the straw lengthwise and flatten it out the helix will become a series of lines sloped at 20° (or whatever the cant angle of the bearings is). The width of the flattened straw is 1.75mm x pi. Hopefully it is fairly easy to see that the vertical distance between each line is therefore tan(20) * 1.75mm * pi. Which is about 2mm.
For reasons I mentioned above you don't actually get the theoretical pitch. In practice I am presently getting about 1.55mm at "normal" printing speeds (by which I mean anything up to about 100mm/s).
-
Thank You, now ist der Groschen gefallen - can´t explain in in english.
I think, I understand it and can find the starting for the setups.Greetings
zero k -
ist der Groschen gefallen
@zero-K Curiously, the phrase translates directly into English and means the same thing. We say "the penny has dropped".
-
@breed 1.75mm comes from weed trimmer wire IIRC.
-
@oliof yep that could be. Didn't think of that.
-
I couldn't resist and tested the NEMA08 motor with filament:
YT-shortIt looks like it's made for it, but as expected the torque is too low.
Maybe with a pushing stationary BLDC motor with limitted torque? SimpleFOC is pretty good with torque control. And the weight of the sensor/driver and step/dir controller (rp2040) wouldn't matter anymore because it's stationary.
-
Hi
OK, compared with yours, it will be something like a monster hollow shaft extruder.
But the first step is done, some parts didn´t arrive yet, may be til next weekend.
Gruß, zero K
-
Been playing around this week in cad. 8mm roller would have to be made on a lathe. 683 bearings. Would make a 2mm lead 2 start thread on the filament. https://www.printables.com/model/573540-extruder-8mm-quick-release
-
@breed That's an interesting approach. The front door is very nice!
But given the relative high RPM we'd need for extruding, I'd prefer a perfectly balanced design, without the knurled screw.
The roller has two bearings inside, I guess , but I don't see a shaft for them?I've made a few suggestions in a quick sketch.
- raise the screw to align with the bearings for equal clamping forces ( red cross marks the spot )
- the cut in the door for the filament is a weak spot in the door. Clamping forces might bend the door and make the bearings contact each other.
I enforced the door on the outside to have same thickness all around. ( grey semicircle )
- raise the screw to align with the bearings for equal clamping forces ( red cross marks the spot
-
@o_lampe The bearings in the door seem to be misoriented- the filament isn't going to be rotating, is it? Also, the threaded insert in the body is going to get jacked out of the body by the spring force on the screw. I think a nut on the back side of the body would be a better way to go. How are you going to rotate the filament drive screw?
-
@mrehorstdmd said in Hollow shaft extruder:
How are you going to rotate the filament drive screw?
The whole part is mounted on the stepper shaft and rotates. That's why I'm worried about the knurled screw being a substantial offcenter mass...
-
@o_lampe I see. I thought the screw was the only rotating part. Interesting approach- much easier to fabricate compared to the designs in the posts above.
