Connectivity
-
@rflulling said in Connectivity:
........................Info is great control is what I need, for tweaking..................
Which is exactly what you get from DWC. You can change any parameter, on the fly, during a print or otherwise. Acceleration, jerk, speed, for any and all axes as well as extruders. Heater parameters, tools, mixing ratios, firmware retraction, linear extrusion advance, pressure advance etc etc. Basically you can input any G or M code, on the fly when printing from SD card. How better to dial in a machine? Make changes and observe the effects "real time".
But hey, who am I too argue. If you insist on using DWC just for monitoring and choose not to use most of the features that Duet give you, then that's entirely up to you I guess.
-
Perhaps you have a misconception on what the Duet Web Control is.
-
@deckingman said in Connectivity:
But hey, who am I too argue. If you insist on using DWC just for monitoring and choose not to use most of the features that Duet give you, then that's entirely up to you I guess.
@deckingman It's not like that. I think you are in your feels bit prematurely. It feels to me like there are a bunch of devs here who have put a lot of work into this and are really defensive of their work the moment I say this doesn't work or I am having an issue. I am not here to tell any of you that you are doing it all wrong and that it doesn't work. But I will ask, as a user for tweaks and improvements, and I will point out what I seem to be bugs. I will provide feedback.
At this time, no one has a one stop solution to everything and the Web Interface is no exception. However I would never wish it to be a one stop solution either. I think that it is great that Duet Products have a web interface. Like any other net-workable product this is a great way to setup, and monitor a device. As said on the parts of my first topic in the web interface forum, there are even a few things I would like to see added that would expand what the interface can offer in terms of data. -Though one of those functions, I have been told is not an option at this time. I have since found some of that data may be useful to display indicators as as Idiot lights via M122 and M305 (this for another topic).
One tool that has been added to the interface is the mixing ratio tool. I do not have a head that Mixes material. So it's a great tool to have but for the moment it would be better to save space and keep it disabled as it does me no use in this setup. Maybe the next. Maybe usefully on a Geetech Rostok Delta?
The web interface is also really huge. I get that it reconfigured itself but it is really good for Touch screen I think. I also don't have a touch screen PC yet. I do have a Leap Motion, but its not much good on my twin 32in, 1920x1080 screens. I think there is much more that can be had on one screen.
If any of the devs here would like to talk about what I think would make the interface better. I think that should probably be best in the proper forum, this conversation would be fully off topic here. -I would be more than happy to list what tools I use and need. Why I do what I do, and maybe all of you can take something from that and the interface can digivolve from really good to even better.
But whatever you are taking away from this, please understand that I have not come here to rip on any of this. I think most of it is really great. But this doesn't mean, it is exactly what I need, and we all need something slightly different. -Have we come to terms?
-
I just think you should give the Duet a chance and explore what it can do for you. Btw, there is only one "dev" for the firmware and that is DC42. The rest of us are just end users like you.
-
@deckingman said in Connectivity:
I just think you should give the Duet a chance and explore what it can do for you. Btw, there is only one "dev" for the firmware and that is DC42. The rest of us are just end users like you.
Actually there are a number of other contributors, in particular chrishamm and more recently wilriker.
-
@deckingman Please believe me, I am. As said I think the Maestro is great and I like just about all of it. This doesn't mean I accept it as perfect or a one stop solution for all needs.
There are things it doesn't have I need, and some of those things as requested were more or less blown off. That's fine. The devs don't want them, and don't feel they are needed. But I do and I do use those features. In the mean time, I have to do things in a way that get done the tasks I am trying to accomplish. Some can be done with Macro. Some require an external controller.
However as said. When the devs are open to constructive criticism, suggestion, and requests, I will be growing a list of things I would like to see added. Capabilities, features, interface, etc. BTW, I was told Duet3 is already under design. I would to contribute "requests and ideas" to that next gen.
@dc42 @deckingman I was able to resolve the USB issue by instructing S3D to disconnect before a reset. Then connect again afterward. This has gone without issue. With this in mind I wonder if there is a command I can add to the Macro that will force a disconnect prior to the reset command, thus removing a step.
-S3D, and Cura do not yet offer a way to SAVE the port like with any other Windows printer (i know, not the same). But as long as S3D is not closed with the port inactive, as of a couple updates back will look to the last good connection to retry before any others.
So if the Macro were to dump the connection a moment before the Reset command, the next time I send an instruction from S3D it will auto reconnect. This isn't a huge thing but it simplifies a few things. If such a command exists.My Wanhao, i3 Mini, is now fully operational. Fully calibrated.
*Ran the file included with the Mini on it's SD card for the CT3D.xyz Benchy. Direct from the Web Interface over night. It is far from perfect but, its a generic slice done by some one else another time, another place. But it is the final test in signing off this machine as being back in full operation.
*I look forward to making all the details available to any one who wants to look at trying out a Duet controller with their i3 Mini.Now moving on to my Folgertech FT-6.
-
If your building an FT-6 consider a proper 1/4 (or thicker) Mic6 or ATP-5 build plate, the stock beds from folgertech are almost useless without glass- I have a FT-5, also I am in the process of bumping the sticks they call Z rods to proper 12mm ones.
I also highly dislike tethered printing, SD card printing is far more reliable, and with the Duet being able to monitor and adjust stuff on the fly with G-code I see no reason not to just put files on the system SD card, With some prints ranging to 2 3 or even 5 days, that is a lot of time for a single hiccup to ruin your efforts.
-
I am aware of the glass sheet issue and it has been my intent to do this but have been unsure how to bind the Glass to the Aluminum without the bonding agent coming loose or burning off.
If your building an FT-6 consider a proper 1/4 (or thicker) Mic6 or ATP-5 build plate, the stock beds from folgertech are almost useless without glass.
The lead screws I have had issues with for Three reasons. The whole Z-Axis drive mechanism seems half baked, and it required changes. With those changes made its is now functional, but due to the lack of accurate mounting holes the bearings brass nuts don't seat square and centered. This makes the rods ride at strange angles. The 4x 8mm rods are fine. But the 2x 8mm ACME screws are not long enough to reach through the guide holes, and I have needed to add flange bearings to catch the rods and stabilize them. But then the bed is unable to rise all the way to the top. So, ya fighting the kit. And this is just a few of several battles in getting the kit to operational.
I have a FT-5, also I am in the process of bumping the sticks they call Z rods to proper 12mm ones.
I agree. However I am not sure the fans understand this. I support the SD card operation. But I do not tweak from there. I will run from a SD card when I think that everything is good and there is no reason for me to be involved. So those big files, no argument in running them from a card, if I am confident it will come out as expected. If not, its going to get run direct.
I also highly dislike tethered printing, SD card printing is far more reliable, and with the Duet being able to monitor and adjust stuff on the fly with G-code I see no reason not to just put files on the system SD card, With some prints ranging to 2 3 or even 5 days, that is a lot of time for a single hiccup to ruin your efforts.
-
@rflulling What do you control from Simplify3D that you can't control from the web interface? I'm genuinely curious, as I don't have S3D.
-
@rflulling I am using 3m MP sheets, I simply put a 2 inch wide strip across two sides. So far so good until my sheet of 1/4 tooling plate comes in. There is a small air gap, but I've had great sucess with hair spray, no problems with bonding or warps.
I like Folgertech, but I see them as a starter kit to add your own parts and ideas. -
What I am missing is a connection for storing g-code files directly from the slicer program (in my case Cura) to the Duet.
Maybe that’s more an issue of windows, cause it’s not possible to mount ftp-recourses as drive without 3-party tools.
There are some freeware tools available to do the job, but I haven’t found one witch fulfils all my requests.
As nowadays it’s more common to use Webdav than FTP, I would prefer a more modern solution. -
@diy-o-sphere Cura has a plugin to upload directly to the Duet. And slic3r PE has it built in.
-
@phaedrux
Thank you, I will try that way.... -
@phaedrux
Great, it works like a charm... -
- I do not have to E-stop or Pause and then Cancel.
- I can just Stop, and raise the heck with two clicks.
-
I can adjust Temp, Rate of extrusion, Speed of movement and execution.
The interface does not offer anything to adjust rates while in progress.Edit: The web interface does offer Speed factor and Extrusion factor, but it is buried, and of course only offers functionality if the file is run from the SD card. I expect to have all the tweaking done before a file is finalized and sen to the SD card. Temp I will assume is adjustable but I am not certain to what level. For now. These tools are, simpler to access and execute from the Controller. -
There are a few more tools I would love to have that neither interface offer. Some, would have me believe it is all perfect and there is nothing that can or should be improved.
-
S3D can upload from the controller screen.
-
I prefer to use the upload function of the Web Interface as the network is far faster for moving the files than the USB port is. And much like the config files, I sometimes edit the gcode files to make tiny tweaks after slicing, and after upload, or to double check markup language for errors based on something I have read, or an observed behavior.
-
@rflulling said in Connectivity:
I can adjust Temp, Rate of extrusion, Speed of movement and execution. The interface does not offer anything to adjust rates while in progress.
...but all of that can be done in the web interface.
-
You can even edit your accelerations, stepper current and more while you are printing- essentially anything and everything, just enter the command in the console.
Also baby stepping for that first layer.
I can't go back to a regular board anymore.
-
-
Not messing with the baby step thing. Took a bit to figure out what that was and why it was needed. It's a hardware calibration screen tool, I think poorly arranged in the interface.
-
I set an offset in the Home files, as is literately built in by default. Works great.
-
No idea what you are talking about adjusting Stepper Current. I think this might be a nice tool to have. But it is not in there now on any interface I know. Less you are literally referring to the the global value (XYZ all) effecting Speed Factor slider.
-
Maybe you love being tied to a command line, but I only do this when experimenting with new tricks, or new codes or troubleshooting. Yes I use the command line, but I am not standing around looking for a reason to run code through it, on any interface.
@wyvern said in Connectivity:
You can even edit your accelerations, stepper current and more while you are printing- essentially anything and everything, just enter the command in the console.
-
-
I would take a screen shot, but on the duet control menu you can pull down files such as config.g edit them there or copy and paste in the command line and hit enter, it will load up the new values right there, printing or not- it's stupid easy- I'm not from a coding background, but dabbled a bit with drones and game hacking- I can't tell you what every command does, but I just use a cheat sheet and add descriptions in configuration files.
What I mean by current is the current to steppers, X,Y,Z,E or whatever, Imagine you are getting hot motors, or your extruder is wanting to miss a step or two, you can raise or lower the values without interrupting the print or compiling anything.
Imagine you are noticing some ringing in your print, you COULD slow the print down, but that affects everything, including your move and retract speeds, you could go in to config.g adjust what you need or if you are using adaptive acceleration control, lower or raise the value on any and every axis.
Baby step is a great tool if you goof on the G-code print and need to bump the Z up or down a smidgen, without stopping, re-slicing and trying again.
All I'm saying is the web control is far more useful and advanced than any slicer program I've used or seen- I use cura to do the slicing and use the duet control to adjust, tune, swap filament on the fly.
You may think configuring machine settings while printing is pointless, but it saved my tail on a 3 day long print! my extruder was starting to skip when I swapped filament, extruder temp was fine, so I bumped it up and it finished the job no worries- sure I COULD have bumped up the temp and hope for the best, but I wasn't going to waste 2 days for it to fail.
-
