Duet3 config Frustration

BlueDust

@Phaedrux
I updated my documentation based on what I saw in the configurator, originally recorded while I was wiring up the printer... As the configurator had at least 1 mistake, and I misinterpreted other items... I will have to redo the docs and will share it once completed.
Thanks!

BlueDust

@dhusolo
I will review (and already started).

Thanks!

BlueDust

@Rushmere3D
I have a relay attached to OUT3/Temp2 for the bed. Works fine, but as it doesn't heat up as fast as the Duet3 expects, I need to PID Auto Tune it....
But your right. I didn't think about it before, but should have assigned the temp to the same OUT #.

Rushmere3D

@BlueDust

I'd be interested is see some pictures of your setup.

What voltage bed are you using etc?

A Former User

@BlueDust said in Duet3 config Frustration:

@BlueDust said in Duet3 config Frustration:

4...
No idea where this came from. If I delete the text, I am still able to change the temp without issue.

Fixed this... Tool config was backwards after I fixed something else...

I have endured this since RRF-3 began, it must be a bug somewhere as I can boot random machines and it's there, and as you say you can still use the heater, and you can "clear" it by inputting a temp, then other days I can boot the very same machine and the temp shows room temp as normal.

Phaedrux

@BlueDust said in Duet3 config Frustration:

@BlueDust said in Duet3 config Frustration:

4...
No idea where this came from. If I delete the text, I am still able to change the temp without issue.

Fixed this... Tool config was backwards after I fixed something else...

Did you fix that T0 is using Heater1 and T1 is using Heater0?

BlueDust

@Rushmere3D
the build is still in progress...
The Electronics are on the bottom of the printer and as it's large for the space, I have to move it to another room to flip it over and have room to work... Picture from last time I had access.
The power supply attached to the acrylic is only for the Duet3/Rpi. 2nd power supply on the floor just for the bed. Both are 24v.

Rushmere3D

@BlueDust

So your using a DC to DC SSR for the bed, correct? You can do that via the OUT0, like I do for my 240v bed (with appreciate SSR of course)

BlueDust

Front printer is the IDEX with the Duet3 I am working on now. Back CoreXY has a Duet2/Duex5. Once the IDEX is working I plan to clean up the CoreXY. Both are RatRig kits. v-Core Pro (not standard upgrade to Pro) is the CoreXY and IDEX is the v-Cast. CoreXY may print up to a 300mm cube once I am done with modifications and the v-Cast is supposed to be 300x 300y and 400z, but haven't had a chance to confirm that yet. Once sensorless homing works will confirm.

BlueDust

@Rushmere3D
Yes, because I didn't know you could. I thought it was only working if you had power in on OUT0. Looking at @dhusolo github pictures this morning, I saw that, that was actually possible. As it is all wired in, I am not sure if I am going to change it at the moment (but I want to now to clean it up).

BlueDust

@Phaedrux

Swapped the P1 and P0 in the G10 commands.

; Tools
;M563 P0 S"LeftExtruder" D0 H0 F0:3                 ; define tool 0
M563 P1 S"RightExtruder" D0 H0 F0:3                 ; 
G10 P1 X0 Y0 Z0                                    ; set tool 0 axis offsets
G10 P1 R0 S0                                       ; set initial tool 0 active and standby temperatures to 0C
;M563 P1 S"RightExtruder" D1 H1 F1:2                ; define tool 1
M563 P0 S"LeftExtruder" D1 H1 F1:2                ; 
G10 P0 X0 Y0 Z0                                    ; set tool 1 axis offsets
G10 P0 R0 S0                                       ; set initial tool 1 active and standby temperatures to 0C

BlueDust

@CaLviNx
So far my biggest problem has been the fans (though right now only one is giving me grief) and the heaters assignment. Will share snapshot of picture/heaters assignment to each tool. OUT3 is also missing from the IO tab heater assignment options.

Among the wrong heaters heating up (the configurator and how each IO device is associated to items on the other tabs..). Example:
Fan mapping on the IO page are static. What does FAN0, FAN1, FAN2, FAN3 refer to? Are they just designations for the configurator?
Then on the Fan tab, I can rename them. Are they referring to the same FAN0 to 3? If so, why would I rename them? And shouldn't they only be renamed on the IO tab, and then auto update to the other tabs?

This confused me again on this page, as I had to again change it in the config on the printer, but when looking at the heaters, only 1 shows up. Shouldn't there be 4??? OUT0 to OUT3?

Another thing is that when you import a saves json/config, you have to fix the IO page to say not assigned. It took me a long time to figure out thats what caused the error before I could save a new config to test again...

Phaedrux

Thanks for the screen shots. They confirm that these are previously reported bugs in the config tool. I believe the plan is to revise the tool once 3.2 is final.

Phaedrux

@BlueDust said in Duet3 config Frustration:

Fan mapping on the IO page are static. What does FAN0, FAN1, FAN2, FAN3 refer to? Are they just designations for the configurator?
Then on the Fan tab, I can rename them. Are they referring to the same FAN0 to 3? If so, why would I rename them? And shouldn't they only be renamed on the IO tab, and then auto update to the other tabs?

They are referred to as fan0 etc because the fans are created in that order and that's how they would be assigned to tools. It's a bit more abstract on the Duet3 since there are no dedicated fan outputs like on other boards.

BlueDust

@Phaedrux
Thanks!
I will most likely go through this again once the configurator has been fixed and compare the code. Is there a thread I can watch to be notified when it has been updated?

Rushmere3D

Reading this might also be useful for the setup.https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Connecting_and_configuring_fans

Phaedrux

@BlueDust said in Duet3 config Frustration:

Is there a thread I can watch to be notified when it has been updated?

You could watch the config tool forum to get notified of new posts. Announcements about it should probably go there.

chrishamm

@BlueDust Starting from RRFv3 you must create heaters and fans on the I/O mapping page before you can configure them in the following pages. I agree this split isn't ideal but it was necessary to keep RRFv2 and RRFv3 supported at the same time (for Duet 2 series). We'll make this more intuitive and extensive in the following version soon.

Be aware that out0 to out3 are no heaters by default unless you assign them first on the I/O mapping page - you could use them for different functions as well. Likewise there are no fans before you define them there. Once you map heaters, you can assign them to tools on the Tools page as well.

If the issue with invalid endstop pins is still present (i.e. it's empty + white without error highlighting), please let me know how you can reproduce it and I'll fix it.

BlueDust

@chrishamm said in Duet3 config Frustration:

If the issue with invalid endstop pins is still present (i.e. it's empty + white without error highlighting), please let me know how you can reproduce it and I'll fix it.

If you are referring to the the highlighted...

It occurs when I load a previously saved JSON file back into the configurator.

BlueDust

@Phaedrux
I am powering a SBC/RPi4 from my Duet3, and curious if I should be doing this.
I saw posts about possible power problems, and RPis not working properly when powered from the Duet3. Is this something I should be concerned about (and power the Rpi4 from another source) or is it just a problem with a specific version of Duet3 (that's planned to be fixed)?
I read through at least one thread, but didn't come away with confirmed answer... (may have just missed it)

Thanks!