Duet3D PCB delta printer effector sneak preview
-
does it possible to mount titan extruder on it?
-
does it possible to mount titan extruder on it?
It's not designed for that. IMO a standard Titan would be too heavy for a delta anyway, it weighs about 260g. If you want to use a direct drive extruder on a delta, you need one with much smaller motor.
-
does it possible to mount titan extruder on it?
IMHO the best solution is the Zesty Nimble (27 grammes on the effector instead of over 200) the motor is remote mounted on the frame somewhere and transmits its power thru a cable/sleeve system pretty much like an older car Speedo drive cable using the correct adapter from either Shapeways or Thingiverse You can see photos of the set up on a previous page but i have posted some better ones here.
HTH Doug
edit links to adaptors added
Shapeways https://www.shapeways.com/product/62MB3QZJ7/nimble-mount-base-pcb-effector?optionId=62810434
Thingiverse https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:2453322
-
Or the flex3drive (in the interests of fairness). Which does the same thing.
Both of these options are IMO much better for a delta than a direct extruder, even a titan with 20mm motor (which works really well) is around 230g which is a lot to add to your effector. These are much better than using bowden tubes albeit a well tuned bowden with pressure advance and as short a tube as possible (flying extruder setup for example) can be quite successful.
I have an aluminium effector currently with flex3drive and e3d v6, and its total mass is 250g, it would be twice the mass with a direct titan, even with a minimal motor. I am looking forward to trying the PCB effector, which should be even lighter. If you truly never want to print at speed then the added mass is not really a problem, but then why opt for a delta unless you want to maximise one of its key attributes - lightweight printhead, enabling accuracy at speed?
There is another option and that is a lightweight adaptor which is the shape/size of a nema 17 but is driven by a drive cable, so you can reduce the mass of your titan extruder's motor to a lot less than it currently weighs. This enables you to mount a titan on an effector with less mass than with a motor attached but you would need to come up with a mounting option to attach it to the pcb effector.
-
Bear in mind that to use the Nimble with the production effector, you will need a different adaptor compared to the prototype that Doug used. The new heatsink doesn't come with the threaded collar that the old one did, instead there is a shorter threaded section and a M12 fine pitch half nut and washer. OTOH the effector now has 3 additional 2.9mm holes at 120 degree intervals on a 17mm radius.
-
I am assuming that the kit will be available at Filastruder here in the US?
If so, will there be a large lag in availability? -
The PCB Effector with Nimble and mounting adaptor plus custom E3D V6 comes in at 159 grammes.
Don't know how the Flex would fit TBH the mounting for the custom heatsink is 3x M3 holes on a 18mm PCD which would be tight.
Right time to go put it back on the printer
Doug
-
Ah David I thought that the only change was in the thread didn't realise that the Collar was no longer included. That may mess things up a bit?
Doug
-
The new heatsink doesn't come with the threaded collar that the old one did, instead there is a shorter threaded section and a M12 fine pitch half nut and washer. OTOH the effector now has 3 additional 2.9mm holes at 120 degree intervals on a 17mm radius.
Ah, OK, no problem. New adapter up and coming!
David, do yo know the height of the top surface to the PCB?Lykle
-
The new heatsink doesn't come with the threaded collar that the old one did, instead there is a shorter threaded section and a M12 fine pitch half nut and washer. OTOH the effector now has 3 additional 2.9mm holes at 120 degree intervals on a 17mm radius.
Ah, OK, no problem. New adapter up and coming!
David, do yo know the height of the top surface to the PCB?Lykle
Not including the collet, it's close to 7.5mm.
EDIT: I just checked the heatsink drawing and it's 8mm from the PCB centering step to the top. Allowing for the 1.6mm PCB thickness, that should leave 7.4mm from the top of the PCB. The top of the half nut is approximately flush with the top of the heatsink.
-
OK, that will work.
Then I can clamp the adapter on top of that and lock the PTFE tube in, without need for the collet.
-
The PCB Effector with Nimble and mounting adaptor plus custom E3D V6 comes in at 159 grammes.
Don't know how the Flex would fit TBH the mounting for the custom heatsink is 3x M3 holes on a 18mm PCD which would be tight.
http://i1014.photobucket.com/albums/af270/dougal1957/DSC_0117_zps5zgaq1gs.jpg
Right time to go put it back on the printer
Doug
where is the fan for the print piece?
we need one to have good quality print.i agree the nimble is top notch but if i need to buy everything i will have for 280e only for the head..110euro for arm+rod kit+ 60euro for pcb+100 with shpping cost for nimble..it s a lot expansive
it s almost the price for my anycubic i3 mega only for parts.. -
I hav'nt included the part fan as I use the Berdair system
-
That's a nice feature being able to disconnect it easily, due to the magnets and the electrical couplings used. Is there one connector for the whole effector, or multiple connectors?
-
OK, new adapter is available.
This adapter is mounted onto the PCB using 6.6 mm tall standoffs. The PCB has 3 holes of 2.9 mm diameter and the adapter has space for 3 M2.5 bolts that go through the standoffs.The bottom of the adapter sits on top of the hot end and has a 4mm opening that is 5 mm deep. This hole is for the PTFE tube. It locks the tube into the hot end, so that there is no need for the collet.
edit: corrected the standoff length.
-
Bear in mind that to use the Nimble with the production effector, you will need a different adaptor compared to the prototype that Doug used. The new heatsink doesn't come with the threaded collar that the old one did, instead there is a shorter threaded section and a M12 fine pitch half nut and washer. OTOH the effector now has 3 additional 2.9mm holes at 120 degree intervals on a 17mm radius.
Damn, I ordered the adapter from shapeways last weekend..
Hopefully they are able to cancel the order
-Jannis
-
OK, new adapter is available.
This adapter is mounted onto the PCB using 7.4 mm tall standoffs. The PCB has 3 holes of 2.9 mm diameter and the adapter has space for 3 M2.5 bolts that go through the standoffs.The bottom of the adapter sits on top of the hot end and has a 4mm opening that is 5 mm deep. This hole is for the PTFE tube. It locks the tube into the hot end, so that there is no need for the collet.
Will this be available from shapeways too?
I ordered the Nimble today (and already got the tracking number)-Jannis
-
DJ there are 2 connectors on it a 8 way single row for thesensors etc and a 3x2 for heater fan and thermistors/temp sensor it took me about 3 minutes to take it of the machine for the photo
-
Hello. It's my first message in this forum but I has been reading it for a few month. Sorry for my english it's not my native language. I'm going to build my first delta 3D printer based on David's Kossel XL. I've got almost all main mechanical parts: extrusions, buildplate, heater, stepper motors etc. Now I'm waiting for the PCB effector to order it with electronics (Duet an so on). On the way to me is the Nimble extruder which I want to pair with the effector. Reading this thread I got sure that the adaptor from shapeways allow me to do that (obviously can't print it myself). But now I see that I need a new version of the adaptor. So it is a question. Can I order this new adaptor from shapeways right now or should I wait some time before this version will be available there? Thanks in advance.
Oleg -
