Problems from the second layer to the 7th layer
-
@carlinicompetizione A raspberry pi does not help here. There is some chance that this is not a software, but a hardware issue, i.e. the mechanism raising the nozzle (or lowering the bed) may be binding until it overcomes the early layers.
You could try commanding the printer without issuing a full print, doing moves with the G0 and G1 commands after homing, to see how things behave.
<>RatRig V-Minion Fly Super5Pro RRF<> V-Core 3.1 IDEX k*****r <> RatRig V-Minion SKR 2 Marlin<>
-
@carlinicompetizione This sounds more like backlash in the Z axis, or the Z axis is sticking when it changes direction. If you move the bed up, then move it down in small increments, eg 0.1mm, does it move straight away, or only after a few moves? What Z height does DWC report at the beginning of the print, and what height when the bed starts to move? If you can see the Z motors, do they move, but the bed does not?
When you start a print, do you use baby stepping? Is the Z probe calibrated for Z height correctly?
Ian
Cartesian bed-slinger with Duet 3 Mini 5+ WiFi and 1LC : RRP Fisher Delta v1 with Duet 2 Maestro : TronXY X5S with Duet 3 MB6HC and Roto toolboard
-
So, it's not a mechanical problem, because it makes the home without problems or locks. the printer has large dimensions 400x 700 mm and Nema 17 motors of 0.8 kg/cm2, if there were any blockages the motors would make noise. In fact, they move, correcting the height of the Z of the map throughout the construction of the first layer, when it is finished, it does not change height for the next one and begins to deposit plastic, thickening too much. From the third layer onwards you feel the movement of the z when changing to the next layer.
-
Yes, I use CR touch to create the map and I placed the M 374-M375 and M376 without success, it looks the same
I use Baby step to get the first layer right, which looks really good. From then on it does another three layers without going down, from the fourth down it goes down normally. -
@carlinicompetizione I can hardly imagine that the machine would ignore some Z motion commands and then suddenly respect them again. Maybe share the start of a gcode file up to the layer where things work again?
<>RatRig V-Minion Fly Super5Pro RRF<> V-Core 3.1 IDEX k*****r <> RatRig V-Minion SKR 2 Marlin<>
-
I will place a dial indicator on the table and activate the fan on the third layer to check if there is a change in the Z height
-
I've read a forum where this happens, but I lost the link and I can't find anything about it, it gave some instructions to read. If I barely remember, the problem was related to a conflict with self-leveling that removed the first layers from the first.
-
In the settings made on the board, there is something wrong or something that could be improved or something that is missing. I know about jerk accelerations to some instruction that is missing for the automatic height adjustment in Z with the CR touch.
-
@carlinicompetizione have you tried reducing the Z speed and acceleration limits in the M203 and M201 commands? Your Z acceleration value in particular looks high to me.
-
I use Baby step to get the first layer right, which looks really good.
How much do you need to babystep to get the first layer looking good?
Can you post the first 100-200 lines of a Gcode file that causes this problem? Or upload a whole Gcode file somewhere so we can take a look? It's possible the slicer is inserting speed/acceleration/jerk settings that are overriding those set in config.g.
Some errors in your config.g:
; Aguarde um momento para que as placas de expansão CAN iniciem o G4 S2Remove the
ofrom the beginning of the line.M566 X500,00 Y500,00 Z300,00 E1200,00 ; definir alterações instantâneas máximas de velocidade (mm/min)Do not use commas for decimal point. Use decimal point:
.;M208 X0 Y0 Z0 S1 ; definir mínimos do eixoYou have commented out the M208 minimum, but X0 Y0 Z0 is the default.
Check your config.g is valid by sending
M98 P"config.g", and check the response in the console. If there are any errors, please post the response in your reply.Ian
Cartesian bed-slinger with Duet 3 Mini 5+ WiFi and 1LC : RRP Fisher Delta v1 with Duet 2 Maestro : TronXY X5S with Duet 3 MB6HC and Roto toolboard
-
@droftarts said in Problems from the second layer to the 7th layer:
M98 P"config.g"
Hello, Ian
I did the request and here is the answerM98 P"config.g"HTTP is enabled on port 80
FTP is enabled on port 21
TELNET is disabled
Height map saved to file 0:/sys/heightmap.csv
Error: Failed to load height map from file 0:/sys/heightmap.csv: invalid grid -
400 lines Gcode with problem
G-Code generated by Simplify3D(R) Version 5.1.2 ; Jun 20, 2024 at 10:52:46 PM ; Settings Summary ; processName,PLA ; autoConfigureMaterial,PLA ; autoConfigureQualidade,High ; targetModels,suporte encoder Honda k20 ; profileName,Projeto Uno ; profileVersion,2024-05-08 17:07:31 ; app,S3D-Software 5.1.2 ; technology,fff ; baseProfile,Default ; extruder,Extruder 1 ; toolheadNumber,0 ; nozzleDiameter,0.80000 ; extrusionMultiplier,0.55000 ; extrusionWidthMode,manual ; extrusionWidth,0.62000 ; useRetraction,1 ; retractDistance,6.50000 ; extraRestartDistance,0.20000 ; retractVerticalLift,0.00000 ; retractSpeed,600.00000 ; useCoasting,1 ; coastingDistance,2.10000 ; useWiping,1 ; wipingDistance,6.00000 ; speedMaxFlowRate,900.00000 ; toolheadOffsetX,0.00000 ; toolheadOffsetY,0.00000 ; filamentDiameter,1.75000 ; filamentPricePerKilogram,46.00000 ; filamentDensity,1.25000 ; primaryExtruder,Extruder 1 ; layerHeight,0.20000 ; topSolidLayers,7 ; bottomSolidLayers,1 ; outlinePerimeters,5 ; useVaseMode,0 ; useAdaptiveLayerHeights,0 ; minAdaptiveLayerHeight,0.10000 ; maxAdaptiveLayerHeight,0.40000 ; adaptiveSmoothingLevel,5 ; horizontalOuterCompensation,0.00000 ; horizontalInnerCompensation,0.00000 ; firstLayerUnits,percentage ; firstLayerHeightPercentage,117 ; firstLayerWidthPercentage,100 ; firstLayerSpeedPercentage,80 ; firstLayerHeightAbsolute,0.30000 ; firstLayerWidthAbsolute,0.40000 ; firstLayerSpeedAbsolute,900.00000 ; startPointStrategy,closest ; alignStartPointsX,0.00000 ; alignStartPointsY,0.00000 ; restrictStartPoints,0 ; perimeterPrintingOrder,inside_out ; islandPrintingOrder,closest ; printInfillBeforePerimeters,0 ; useSkirt,1 ; skirtExtruder,Extruder 1 ; skirtLayers,1 ; skirtOffset,0.00000 ; skirtOutlines,15 ; useRaft,0 ; raftExtruder,Extruder 1 ; raftBaseLayers,2 ; raftTopLayers,3 ; raftOffset,3.00000 ; raftSeparationDistance,0.14000 ; raftSpeedUnits,percentage ; raftSpeedPercentage,30 ; raftSpeedAbsolute,600.00000 ; usePrimePillar,0 ; primePillarExtruder,All Extruders ; primePillarWidth,12.00000 ; primePillarLocation,north_west ; primePillarSpeedPercentage,100 ; primePillarInfillPercentage,100 ; autoStopPrimePillar,1 ; primePillarLayersAfterAutoStop,0 ; useOozeShield,0 ; oozeShieldExtruder,All Extruders ; oozeShieldOffset,2.00000 ; oozeShieldOutlines,1 ; oozeShieldSidewallShape,waterfall ; oozeShieldSidewallAngle,30 ; oozeShieldSpeedPercentage,100 ; autoStopOozeShield,1 ; oozeShieldLayersAfterAutoStop,0 ; sparseInfillExtruder,Extruder 1 ; sparseInfillPattern,fast_honeycomb ; sparseInfillRotation,0 ; sparseInfillPercentage,30 ; sparseInfillExtrusionWidthPercentage,115 ; sparseInfillCombinedLayers,1 ; denseInfillLayers,0 ; denseInfillPercentage,55 ; infillOutlineOverlapPercentage,15 ; minInfillLength,1.00000 ; externalInfillPattern,rectilinear ; externalInfillRotation,0 ; solidInfillThresholdArea,25.00000 ; solidInfillExtraExpansion,0.00000 ; useMonotonic,1 ; useDiaphragm,0 ; diaphragmSolidLayers,3 ; diaphragmSpacingLayers,20 ; topLayerExtraExpansion,0.00000 ; topLayerExtrusionModifier,100 ; overrideFanSpeedForTopLayer,0 ; topLayerFanSpeedPercentage,100 ; useIroning,0 ; ironingOutlineOffsetPercentage,50 ; ironingExtrusionWidthPercentage,25 ; ironingExtrusionModifier,15 ; ironingSpeedModifier,30 ; sparseSupportExtruder,Extruder 1 ; sparseSupportInfillPattern,aligned ; sparseSupportInfillRotation,0 ; sparseSupportInfillPercentage,25 ; sparseSupportOutlines,0 ; sparseSupportCombinedLayers,1 ; upperDenseSupportLayers,0 ; lowerDenseSupportLayers,1 ; denseSupportExtruder,Extruder 1 ; denseSupportInfillPercentage,50 ; denseSupportExtraExpansion,0.00000 ; baseSupportLayers,0 ; supportInflationDistance,0.00000 ; supportHorizontalPartOffset,0.70000 ; supportUpperSeparationLayers,1 ; supportLowerSeparationLayers,1 ; temperatureController,Extruder 1 ; enableTemperatureController,1 ; temperatureNumber,0 ; temperatureType,extruder ; stabilizeAtStartup,1 ; temperatureSetpoints,1|210,2|195 ; useIdleCooldown,0 ; cooldownTemperature,150 ; cooldownRequiredIdleTime,180 ; cooldownReheatTime,60 ; temperatureController,Heated Bed ; enableTemperatureController,1 ; temperatureNumber,0 ; temperatureType,platform ; stabilizeAtStartup,1 ; temperatureSetpoints,1|60 ; useIdleCooldown,0 ; cooldownTemperature,150 ; cooldownRequiredIdleTime,180 ; cooldownReheatTime,60 ; fan,Ventoinha ; fanNumber,0 ; fanType,extruder ; blipFanToFullPower,0 ; fanSetpoints,1|0,2|100 ; increaseFanForQuickLayers,0 ; fanMaxQuickLayerTime,45.00000 ; fanMinQuickLayerTime,15.00000 ; maxQuickLayerFanSpeedPercentage,100 ; defaultPrintSpeed,2400.00000 ; outerPerimeterSpeedPercentage,50 ; innerPerimeterSpeedPercentage,80 ; topLayerSpeedPercentage,50 ; solidInfillSpeedPercentage,80 ; sparseSupportSpeedPercentage,80 ; denseSupportSpeedPercentage,70 ; travelSpeedXY,4800.00000 ; travelSpeedZ,1002.00000 ; reduceSpeedForQuickLayers,1 ; speedMaxQuickLayerTime,15.00000 ; minQuickLayerSpeedPercentage,20 ; reduceSpeedForShortPerimeters,1 ; speedMaxShortPerimeterLength,80.00000 ; minShortPerimeterSpeedPercentage,50 ; reduceSpeedForMaxFlowRate,0 ; accelXY,1000.00000 ; accelZ,150.00000 ; accelE,3000.00000 ; jerkXY,600.00000 ; jerkZ,24.00000 ; jerkE,300.00000 ; exportFileFormat,gcode ; useStickyCommands,1 ; use5D,1 ; relativeExtrusionDistances,0 ; allowExtruderAxisZeroing,1 ; independentExtruderAxes,0 ; includeM10123,0 ; includeThumbnailImages,0 ; thumbnailImageEncoding,standard ; thumbnailImageSizes,300|300 ; x3gMachineProfile,r2 ; overrideStepsPerMillimeter,0 ; stepsPerMillimeterX,88.57319 ; stepsPerMillimeterY,88.57319 ; stepsPerMillimeterZ,400.00000 ; stepsPerMillimeterA,96.27520 ; stepsPerMillimeterB,96.27520 ; xyzFileFormatVersion,1 ; makerBotMachineProfile,replicator_5 ; makerBotModelExtruder,mk13 ; makerBotSupportExtruder,mk14_s ; makerBotModelMaterial,pla ; makerBotSupportMaterial,pva ; globalOffsetX,0.00000 ; globalOffsetY,0.00000 ; globalOffsetZ,0.00000 ; applyToolheadOffsets,0 ; buildVolumeShape,rectangular ; buildVolumeX,700.00000 ; buildVolumeY,400.00000 ; buildVolumeZ,400.00000 ; buildVolumeDiameter,200.00000 ; originOffsetX,0.00000 ; originOffsetY,0.00000 ; originOffsetZ,0.00000 ; homingDirectionX,min ; homingDirectionY,min ; homingDirectionZ,min ; mirrorVisualX,0 ; mirrorVisualY,1 ; mirrorVisualZ,0 ; machineBackgroundModel, ; startingScript,M140 S60; faz aquecimento cama |G28; HOME GERAL|G29 V4 T ; AUTO NIVELAMENTO|G1 Y0 Z25 F8000; VAI PRA PONTO DE PURGA|G1 X0 F8000|G1 E60 F250; PURGA FILAMENTO|G92 E0; RESETA EXTRUSOR|G1 X350 F8000 |G1 Y200 Z0 F8000 ; MOVIMENTO para iniciar a impressao ; preLayerChangeScript, ; postLayerChangeScript, ; preRetractionScript, ; postRetractionScript, ; preToolChangeScript, ; postToolChangeScript, ; processChangeScript, ; endingScript,G1 Z300 F6000|M104 S0 ; turn off extruder|M140 S0 ; turn off bed|M84 ; disable motors ; postProcessingScript, ; useBridging,1 ; bridgingThresholdArea,50.00000 ; bridgingInfillExtraExpansion,0.00000 ; bridgingExtrusionModifier,100 ; bridgingSpeedModifier,100 ; overrideFanSpeedForBridging,0 ; bridgingFanSpeedPercentage,100 ; useFixedBridgingAngle,0 ; fixedBridgingAngle,0 ; applyBridgingToPerimeters,0 ; bridgingPerimeterExtraOverlap,0.00000 ; minBridgingPerimeterLength,10.00000 ; useToolChangeRetraction,1 ; toolChangeRetractDistance,12.00000 ; toolChangeExtraRestartDistance,-0.50000 ; toolChangeRetractSpeed,600.00000 ; toolChangePrimeOnFirstUse,0 ; toolChangeRetractAtEnd,0 ; externalThinWallType,perimeters_only ; internalThinWallType,gap_fill ; thinWallAllowedOverlapPercentage,10 ; singleExtrusionMinLength,1.00000 ; singleExtrusionMinWidthPercentage,50 ; singleExtrusionMaxWidthPercentage,200 ; singleExtrusionEndpointExtensionDistance,0.20000 ; onlyRetractWhenCrossingOutlines,1 ; retractBetweenLayers,1 ; retractOnTopLayers,0 ; useRetractionMinTravel,0 ; retractionMinTravel,3.00000 ; useRetractionMinExtrusion,0 ; retractionMinExtrusion,3.00000 ; onlyVerticalLiftOnTopLayers,0 ; retractWhileWiping,0 ; wipingMode,outer_perimeter ; avoidCrossingOutlines,0 ; maxMovementDetourFactor,3.00000 ; openLoopSlicingBehavior,heal ; openLoopThickenWidth,0.50000 ; slicingRegionRepairMode,positive G90 M82 M106 S0 P0 M140 S60 M190 S60 M104 S210 T0 M109 S210 T0 M140 S60; faz aquecimento cama G28; HOME GERAL G29 V4 T ; AUTO NIVELAMENTO G1 Y0 Z25 F8000; VAI PRA PONTO DE PURGA G1 X0 F8000 G1 E60 F250; PURGA FILAMENTO G92 E0; RESETA EXTRUSOR G1 X350 F8000 G1 Y200 Z0 F8000 ; MOVIMENTO para iniciar a impressao ; process PLA ; layer 1, Z = 0.2340 T0 G92 E0.00000 G1 E-6.50000 F600 ; feature skirt ; tool H0.2340 W0.620 G1 Z0.2340 F1002 G1 X321.538 Y175.143 F4800 G92 E0.00000 G1 E6.70000 F600 G92 E0.00000 G1 X322.328 Y173.810 E0.05142 F1920 G1 X323.416 Y172.206 E0.11569 G1 X324.412 Y170.915 E0.16978 G1 X326.044 Y169.079 E0.25128 G1 X327.847 Y167.376 E0.33355 G1 X329.376 Y166.143 E0.39872 G1 X330.287 Y165.482 E0.43606 G1 X331.517 Y164.671 E0.48493 G1 X332.820 Y163.905 E0.53508 G1 X334.162 Y163.208 E0.58525 G1 X335.539 Y162.582 E0.63541 G1 X336.946 Y162.028 E0.68558 G1 X338.454 Y161.524 E0.73833 G1 X340.754 Y160.929 E0.81714 G1 X342.307 Y160.641 E0.86956 G1 X343.807 Y160.443 E0.91975 G1 X345.403 Y160.317 E0.97285 G1 X347.831 Y160.294 E1.05340 G1 X350.265 Y160.482 E1.13440 G1 X351.841 Y160.715 E1.18723 G1 X353.324 Y161.014 E1.23742 G1 X354.789 Y161.390 E1.28759 G1 X356.232 Y161.842 E1.33775 G1 X357.649 Y162.368 E1.38792 G1 X359.038 Y162.968 E1.43808 G1 X360.393 Y163.639 E1.48825 G1 X361.711 Y164.380 E1.53842 G1 X362.989 Y165.188 E1.58859 G1 X364.254 Y166.085 E1.64004 G1 X365.765 Y167.299 E1.70431 G1 X366.913 Y168.343 E1.75580 G1 X367.978 Y169.419 E1.80603 G1 X369.044 Y170.614 E1.85914 G1 X370.482 Y172.473 E1.93712 G1 X371.367 Y173.795 E1.98990 G1 X372.141 Y175.095 E2.04009 G1 X372.846 Y176.433 E2.09026 G1 X373.480 Y177.806 E2.14042 G1 X374.042 Y179.210 E2.19059 G1 X374.530 Y180.641 E2.24076 G1 X374.942 Y182.096 E2.29092 G1 X375.270 Y183.533 E2.33985 G1 X377.187 Y194.033 E2.69391 G1 X379.210 Y196.056 E2.78884 G1 X379.210 Y208.056 E3.18693 G1 X383.210 Y212.056 E3.37460 G1 X383.210 Y231.944 E4.03435 G1 X373.944 Y241.210 E4.46909 G1 X358.056 Y241.210 E4.99615 G1 X354.056 Y237.210 E5.18381 G1 X350.056 Y237.210 E5.31651 G1 X346.056 Y233.210 E5.50417 G1 X342.056 Y233.210 E5.63687 G1 X328.790 Y219.944 E6.25927 G1 X328.790 Y215.691 E6.40035 G1 X321.837 Y203.926 E6.85372 G1 X321.161 Y202.712 E6.89980 G1 X320.457 Y201.275 E6.95290 G1 X319.568 Y199.086 E7.03129 G1 X319.064 Y197.549 E7.08495 G1 X318.574 Y195.675 E7.14921 G1 X318.273 Y194.152 E7.20071 G1 X318.057 Y192.655 E7.25087 G1 X317.917 Y191.110 E7.30235 G1 X317.857 Y189.081 E7.36969 G1 X317.978 Y186.601 E7.45204 G1 X318.308 Y184.184 E7.53297 G1 X318.630 Y182.638 E7.58536 G1 X319.034 Y181.101 E7.63808 G1 X319.822 Y178.775 E7.71956 G1 X320.804 Y176.541 E7.80051 G1 X321.538 Y175.143 E7.85290 G92 E0.00000 G1 E-6.50000 F600 G1 X322.079 Y175.445 F4800 G92 E0.00000 G1 E6.70000 F600 G92 E0.00000 -
@carlinicompetizione said in Problems from the second layer to the 7th layer:
Height map saved to file 0:/sys/heightmap.csv
Error: Failed to load height map from file 0:/sys/heightmap.csv: invalid gridThese errors would be reported by running G29 S3 then G29 S1. I can't see any G29 commands in the config.g you posted earlier, unless you have changed it. You have M501, which runs config_override.g. Can you post that?
In the Gcode output, you are using absolute mode for extrusion; we recommend relative mode (M83)
M82
Also, this line is wrong for RepRapFirmware. This is a Marlin command.
G29 V4 T ; AUTO NIVELAMENTO
I can't see anything else obviously wrong with the Gcode file. It should not changing the motor settings in config.g. It does have some Z movements at maximum speed, so you should try moving the bed at these speeds; try sending the following:
G1 Z25 F8000 G1 Z5 F8000 G1 Z25 F8000 G1 Z5 F8000Can you post the whole Gcode file? Add ".txt" to the end of the file name, and you should be able to upload it to the forum.
Ian
Cartesian bed-slinger with Duet 3 Mini 5+ WiFi and 1LC : RRP Fisher Delta v1 with Duet 2 Maestro : TronXY X5S with Duet 3 MB6HC and Roto toolboard
-
Ian, thank you very much for the guidance, I did as you suggested,
The M208 is actually deactivated, I activated it. The Z tests with perfect F8000 drops 25 5 without any problems! When I send the command G29 S3 and G29 S1 there is an error reading the map and I cannot load it. I'm going to change the CURA configuration to RRPP even today it is with Marlin, but in config.g the command is as M83. -
It may be that the Map is not loading, I need to add some command to the config. g to load and activate the created map?
-
@carlinicompetizione
Check the grid spacing in M557 that doesn't make sense to me.
You have only defined 4 points in the grid. -
@carlinicompetizione said in Problems from the second layer to the 7th layer:
I need to add some command to the config. g to load and activate the created map?
There are several ways to do this.
I have added it to my homing routine.
But it also works at the end of the config.g. However, you must definitely call G29 before printing.
There are also several options for G29. I only load the saved map.
If the printer is stable, the mesh does not need to be recreated each time. -
@carlinicompetizione No, you certainly shouldn't save the map in config.g, as no map is in use; I'm not exactly sure what this does, but most likely creates a blank map, hence the 'invalid grid' error.
Also, you shouldn't load a map during config.g, because you have not homed the Z axis to set the Z datum point.I've just remembered you mentioned putting M374 and M375 in config.g, please remove these. They are synonymous with G29 S3 then G29 S1. M376 is okay.
You should home Z, then load the map or run the mesh bed scan, then home Z again. That will give the most reliable results from a saved mesh. You can do this in homez.g, homeall.g, in the start.g of the slicer, or create the file sys/mesh.g, which is run when G29 is sent. See https://docs.duet3d.com/en/User_manual/Reference/Gcodes#g29-mesh-bed-probe and https://docs.duet3d.com/en/User_manual/Connecting_hardware/Z_probe_mesh_bed
But I don't think this is related to the problem of your machine not moving for the second layer, though you could try a test without mesh bed levelling enabled.
Ian
-
Having activated the M208 seems to have solved the problem, but it is still not going down, do the first one each, and remain in the same Z, it only starts to change from the 4th layer that starts to go down the Z, the second and the third it prints even Z then there is that excess plastic, the interesting thing is that the display shows the value of X,Y, Z, when the extruder moves in the map, this does not show, it is only from the 4th layer that it starts to descend, for example, it starts printing at Z=2 9 this value is the baby step. finishes the first layer and goes to the second and it doesn't change, it stays at Z=2, finishes the second layer and goes to the third and Z=2 continues. When the 4th layer begins, Z = 2.4 because I established a layer height of 0.4 mm in Simplify 3D. in fact it should be at Z=3.6. the extruder starts hitting the print.
-
@oliof said in Problems from the second layer to the 7th layer:
@carlinicompetizione A raspberry pi does not help here. There is some chance that this is not a software, but a hardware issue, i.e. the mechanism raising the nozzle (or lowering the bed) may be binding until it overcomes the early layers.
You could try commanding the printer without issuing a full print, doing moves with the G0 and G1 commands after homing, to see how things behave.
I would like to know if there is a possible solution to this problem that the system has that disregards the first layers?, the printer is industrial, and I have already spent too much time making it work with this Duet 3D 6HC card. I really need a solution, otherwise I have to change my motherboard to another brand that is less problematic and can print without so much hassle.
