Fly-super8 driver extension with BTT EXP-Mot V1.0

oliof

That's crazy. I love it (-:

o_lampe

@oliof I like the ability to define extra stepper drivers by a simple text file in /sys folder.
AFAIK it's not possible with the RRF main branch, but maybe for a good reason?
I'll test them today.

jay_s_uk

@o_lampe spot checking those they look good

oliof

@o_lampe I think the LPC/STM port found the right balance between supporting versatile boards and not requiring recompiles with the board.txt approach.

o_lampe

@jay_s_uk I've added the stepper related lines to board.txt, but M122 P200 still shows:

== Configurable Board.txt Settings ==
board = fly_super8   Signature 0xd0c680ae

leds.diagnostic = NoPin 
stepper.powerEnablePin = NoPin 
stepper.enablePins = { F.11 F.14 G.1 E.9 F.2 C.15 G.4 G.7 NoPin NoPin NoPin }
stepper.stepPins = { E.2 E.3 E.4 E.14 E.15 E.1 E.0 E.6 NoPin NoPin NoPin }
stepper.directionPins = { C.5 F.13 G.0 E.8 E.11 F.0 G.3 G.6 NoPin NoPin NoPin }
stepper.digipotFactor = 0.00 
stepper.TmcUartPins = { C.4 F.12 F.15 E.7 E.10 F.1 G.2 G.5 NoPin NoPin NoPin }
stepper.numSmartDrivers = 11 
stepper.num5160Drivers = 0 
stepper.spiChannel = 255 
stepper.TmcDiagPins = { NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin NoPin }

The board was reset and cold-started several times with no change.
What next? Via chat, if you like

jay_s_uk

@o_lampe Add comma's between each pin

o_lampe

@jay_s_uk @jay_s_uk That helped recognizing the extra drivers.
I coupled the extra driver with the V-axis (V4:8) and it followed like a puppy

Check out driver 4 and 8, there is a difference I can't evaluate:

Driver 0: position -19800, 2209 standstill, reads 4591, writes 11, SG min/max not available
Driver 1: position -19800, 2209 standstill, reads 4590, writes 11, SG min/max not available
Driver 2: position 15920, 2209 standstill, reads 4590, writes 11, SG min/max not available
Driver 3: position 19800, 2209 standstill, reads 4590, writes 11, SG min/max not available
Driver 4: position 23800, 2209 standstill, reads 4586, writes 15, SG min/max 0/14
Driver 5: position 0, 2209 standstill, reads 4590, writes 11, SG min/max not available
Driver 6: position 0, 2209 standstill, reads 4590, writes 11, SG min/max not available
Driver 7: position 0, 2209 standstill, reads 4590, writes 11, SG min/max not available
Driver 8: position 0, 2209 standstill, reads 4586, writes 15, SG min/max 0/438
Driver 9: position 0, no-driver-detected
Driver 10: position 0, no-driver-detected

gloomyandy

@o_lampe said in Fly-super8 driver extension with BTT EXP-Mot V1.0:

Check out driver 4 and 8, there is a difference I can't evaluate:

What is it you are concerned about?

o_lampe

@gloomyandy ..I just don't kknow what SG min/max stands for and if the difference is a problem

gloomyandy

@o_lampe Those are the TMC stall guard readings and will be dependant upon things like motor configuration, motor loading and how the motor has been moved. Are your driver 4 and 8 motors identical from this point of view?

o_lampe

@gloomyandy Thank's for explaining.
No the motors aren't identical, coupling drive 4 with the extra stepper was the fastest way to test it. It runs without anything attached.

gloomyandy

@o_lampe I think that will explain the difference, but it is hard to be 100% sure!

jtimon

@o_lampe Sorry for replying to this old post. But I have an octopus pro (429, with RRF) and I was wordering if I could do this same thing with it. Does anybody in the thread know?
If not, could I expand it somehow else? could I, for example, use the CAN interface to connect it to duet expansion boards or would that not be compatible?
Could I connect several different boards to a raspberry and make them communicate that way, perhaps (I know this is possible in klipper, but not sure about RRF).
Sorry again, perhaps I should start a new thread.

weed2all

@jtimon as I know the only boards that uses CAN-FD compatible with duet boards are skr 3, skr 3 ez and fly super 8, I might be wrong but Jay know for sure!

jay_s_uk

@jtimon you can you the btt-exp-mot to add 3 more drivers if you aren't using EXP1 and EXP2.
As @weed2all said, there are currently only 3 STM boards that support CAN-FD.
And you are correct in that klipper can add multiple boards, RRF can't unless they're CAN-FD compatible

jtimon

@jay_s_uk Thanks a lot.
Well, I was planning on using the EXP1 and EXP2 for a tft but if this is my only option for expansion, oh, well, I can use only the web interface, I guess, no big deal. Having an extra driver for the extruder is more important. Otherwise I could move to a 6 rope configuration from the current 8 rope configuration.
I would to CAD everything again, but I haven't started coding the new kynematics anyway.

Thanks again, I was asking on reddit but not getting many answers:

https://www.reddit.com/r/3Dprinting/comments/wubt9g/is_the_octopus_board_compatible_with_any/

https://www.reddit.com/r/BIGTREETECH/comments/wuysen/how_can_i_expand_an_octopus_pro_429/

jay_s_uk

@jtimon I don't look at Reddit much. For the STM port of RRF you're best seeking support on our discord server https://discord.gg/uS97Qs7
And you can still use a screen using UART assuming the screen supports it