Tool changer commands

RajaaKahel

@whosrdaddy
If I write in tpre0 to park T1 then select T0 during a print that's ok. But then at the beginning of a print it will also do the same (to park T1 then select T0) but T1 is already parked, That will be horrible crash.
As I said I'm pretty confused, so please if you can't explain with simple steps don't confuse me more
Thanks for the input

whosrdaddy

Actually parking T1 should be done in TFree1.g, don't touch other tools in the Txxxx Macro's

T3P3Tony

@RajaaKahel the Duet does not know that a particular T0 command is at the start of a print, or part way through a print, which is why i am suggesting having the appropraite pick up command in your start gcode as included in the slicer.

Alternatively always have the printer have T0 picked up when its in an idle state.

RajaaKahel

@t3p3tony and @whosrdaddy
Thank you for your input! I'll try to figure this out with a new cup of coffee

whosrdaddy

@rajaakahel : I don't know if you read this one too: https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Gcode#Section_T_Select_Tool?
This is the most informative doc about tools and the sequence followed on tool changes.

RajaaKahel

@whosrdaddy
Thank you, I started to make progress finally, after some painful crashes especially with the interference from S3D..

RajaaKahel

Ok, so I removed any parking or picking commands from Simplify3D, and did the following:
; tfree0.g
; called when tool 0 is freed
M98 P/macros/parkT0

; tfree1.g
; called when tool 1 is freed
M98 P/macros/parkT1

; tpre0.g
; called before tool 0 is selected
M98 P/macros/selectT0

; tpre1.g
; called before tool 1 is selected
M98 P/macros/selectT1

It works fine during a print, but at the beginning it doesn't pick any tool, and at the end it doesn't park any tool. Is there a way to fix this?
I noticed that I don't have files such as start.g or end.g in the files section, anyway is there such a start file for T0 and another one for T1? (same for the end?)

T3P3Tony

@rajaakahel glad you got it working on tool change!

start and end gcodes are normally configured in you slicer so you can add the relevant macro calls to your slicer.

One thing I note it that if you don't always start with tool 0 for every print then its probably better to have the "default state " of your printer with the tool changer with tool 1 selected.

RajaaKahel

@t3p3tony Thank you!
Unfortunately Starting Script and Ending Script in Simplify3D don't allow IF commands such as {IF NEWTOOL=0}
It's only allowed in Tool Change Script section.
And as you know each print is different, one time you start with a tool and another time you start with another tool (same for finishing). So I would love to make it automatic..

T3P3Tony

@rajaakahel in that case you are going to have to have a default state of the printer with always having T0 (or T1) selected. So your end script always selects T0 so you know at the start that T0 is selected. That way when the printer changes to T1 it will park T0 and then pickup T1. That should work even if the printer start with T1, as long as S3d explicitly chooses the tool every time.

RajaaKahel

@t3p3tony Thank you very much for your time! I'll look into this closely. I also submitted a request to S3D to allow IF commands in start and end scripts. I hope it can be added later in the Duet firmware as well.
Please can you check my other post whenever you have time?
https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/6517/setting-z-offset-for-t1

dc42

@rajaakahel, make sure you start with no tool selected. You probably have T0 at the end of config.g, if so then remove that. Also include T-1 in your slicer end script to deselect and park the active tool.

RajaaKahel

@dc42 Thank you! I'm still trying to work it out to be full automatic. Will get back to you with the results

RajaaKahel

@dc42 Hello again, I managed to
park any nozzle at the end of a print by putting the following Ending Script in my slicer:

G1 E-15 F4000
M104 S0 ; turn off extruder
M140 S0 ; turn off bed
T0
M98 P/macros/parkT0
G28 X ; home x and y axes
G28 Y ; home x and y axes
M84 ; disable motors
M107
M1

In Duet firmware I have the following:

; tfree0.g
; called when tool 0 is freed
M98 P/macros/parkT0

; tfree1.g
; called when tool 1 is freed
M98 P/macros/parkT1

; tpost0.g
; called after tool 0 is selected
M98 P/macros/selectT0

; tpost1.g
; called after tool 1 is selected
M98 P/macros/selectT1

But the problem is when I start a print, Duet is always activating T0 (even if the first tool to run is T1) when starting to heat up, but it does not actually go and pick T0 tool (so it thinks T0 is already picked up).

I can work this around by picking T0 at the end of each print without parking it. But I want both nozzles to be parked to prevent oozing and stuff.

So the question is: how can I tell the duet to start a print (heat up) without activating any tool until the print gcode tells it to activate (thus pick up) the right tool?

*I don't have T0 or T1 at the end of config.g
*I tried to include T-1 or M1 at the Starting Script of my slicer, but it didn't work. (Duet is always activating T0 regardless of what tool gonna start).
*I tried sending M1 manually before I start a print (to deactivate tools) but same thing happens when a print is started by heating up (activating T0).

zerspaner_gerd

@rajaakahel Make sure that all axes are referenced before the tool command!
Only then will the tool script be triggered!

@rajaakahel said in Tool changer commands:

But the problem is when I start a print, Duet is always activating T0 (even if the first tool to run is T1) when starting to heat up, but it does not actually go and pick T0 tool (so it thinks T0 is already picked up).

Do you have a start.g file? With me the duet does not select a tool at the print start, so you have somewhere a tool command.

@rajaakahel said in Tool changer commands:

I can work this around by picking T0 at the end of each print without parking it. But I want both nozzles to be parked to prevent oozing and stuff.

Does not T-1 work? There must be no M84, M18, M1 before.

G1 E-15 F4000 
M104 S0; Extruder 
M140 S0 ausschalten; Bett ausschalten 
T-1
G28 X; home x und y Achsen 
G28 Y; home x und y Achsen 
M84; Deaktivieren Sie die Motoren 
M107 
M1

@rajaakahel said in Tool changer commands:

So the question is: how can I tell the duet to start a print (heat up) without activating any tool until the print gcode tells it to activate (thus pick up) the right tool?

You can activate tools with T# P0 (# = Tool Number) without changing the tool

https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Multiple_tools_and_Tool_change_macros

RajaaKahel

@zerspaner_gerd
"Make sure that all axes are referenced before the tool command!
Only then will the tool script be triggered!"
You mean by "referenced" homed? if so, then yes they are homed.

"Do you have a start.g file? With me the duet does not select a tool at the print start, so you have somewhere a tool command."
No I don't have a start.g file in the Duet. And in my slicer only G28 is included in the Start Script. I don't find any tool command..

"Does not T-1 work? There must be no M84, M18, M1 before."
I tried T-1 and M1 in the Start Script of my slicer, they do nothing. After I upload a print to the Duet, it immediately choose T0 (but doesn't activate the tpost1.g (same if I manually send T-1 or M1 before I start a print).

You can activate tools with T# P0 (# = Tool Number) without changing the tool
Where should I put T# P0?
Again, Duet is always activating T0 (even if the first tool to run is T1) when starting to heat up, but it does not activate the tpost1.g.

RajaaKahel

Here are all my settings if that helps..
Macros:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1Nwte-EtKEzL_ogCqJp7PMQ2qsLK7RBkM

Configurations:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1q-h8eojJ91CQwK2p5YhWKuQaQph0sQ_T

0_1535131031908_8.gcode

dc42

@rajaakahel said in Tool changer commands:

But the problem is when I start a print, Duet is always activating T0 (even if the first tool to run is T1) when starting to heat up, but it does not actually go and pick T0 tool (so it thinks T0 is already picked up).

That probably means you have either a T0 command or a M109 command near the start of your GCode file before the printer has been homed. M109 or M109 T0 will select T0 implicitly if no tool is selected, and if the printer hasn't been homed than the tool change macros won't be run.

RajaaKahel

@dc42 said in Tool changer commands:

M109

This is my Start and Ending Scripts in Simplify3D, nothing else is there in between:
Start Script:
G1 E15 F3000
G28 ; home all axes
G1 Y37
Ending Script
G1 E-15 F4000
M104 S0 ; turn off extruder
M140 S0 ; turn off bed
T0
;M98 P/macros/parkT0
G28 X ; home x and y axes
G28 Y ; home x and y axes
M84 ; disable motors
M107
M1

I can't find any M109. Where in the Duet I can look for what is causing this? You see I attached all the files in my last post, I can't either find anything in them, please check them yourself too. Maybe my firmware is bad somehow? especially that I have another problem that I have to fix in order for my printer to function! (G10 Z offset for T1 simply doesn't work) as you see here:
https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/6517/setting-z-offset-for-t1/15

Any suggestions please? (at least I have to fix the T1 Z offset issue).

Firmware Name: RepRapFirmware for Duet 2 WiFi/Ethernet
Firmware Electronics: Duet WiFi 1.02 or later
Firmware Version: 1.21 (2018-03-21)
WiFi Server Version: 1.21RC4(08b3)
Web Interface Version: 1.21-RC4

dc42

Please post the first 50 or so lines (not counting comment lines) of the GCode file generated by your slicer. You may find that it has inserted a M109 command before your start GCode.