Anybody using a Duet board with a Klipper SBC?
-
@Luke-sLaboratory any chance you can send me your config file ? Duet 3 mini should be close enought to duet 6hc.. Im still trying to find the stepper address for the 6hc board.
-
Just wanted to add that besides input shaper RRF has more on it's road map:
https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/20602/reprapfirmware-road-map-q1-2021?_=1615749405350
"RRF 3.4: the focus of this will be the motion system. We will be looking at input shaping, S-curve acceleration, better cornering algorithms, and other mechanisms to improve print quality. "
-
@Argo said in Anybody using a Duet board with a Klipper SBC?:
RRF 3.4: the focus of this will be the motion system
Hopefully that release will significantly benefit my Duet2 Wifi, no extenders, no SBC printer. The recent releases seem to be 'for other people'.
BTW, looking more into the Klipper, its two tiers architecture of an SBC tied to heterogenous 'dumb' I/O slaves seems to be simpler, more open, and more promising than the Duet's 3 tier approach of a SBC, a proprietary smart controller and proprietary slave controllers (extenders, tool boards, etc). I like it more and more, but don't have yet real life experience with it.
-
I tested klipper on duet WiFi and deux5 this weekend. I run true bed leveling with it quite fine and the input shaper does magic. The UI is not great compared to duet but I might stay with it because of the magic the input shaper does. Wish I could add a photo here easy and I’ll show the huge difference.
Managed to crash my Z axis during setup so I got some Z banding now but I can’t blame klipper for a user error
-
@minim said in Anybody using a Duet board with a Klipper SBC?:
Wish I could add a photo here easy and I’ll show the huge difference.
copy n' paste and drag n' drop should work for pictures, there is also the upload image icon on the toolbar (second last)
-
@minim said in Anybody using a Duet board with a Klipper SBC?:
The UI is not great compared to duet
I hear this Is a criticism often levelled at Klipper. By no means an endorsement, but I did find this recently: https://github.com/Stephan3/dwc2-for-klipper-socket
Ian
-
@gaweyo It was a bit easier from a pc than from my phone
I have some issues in the Z axis after a crash during config but it still shows great improvement of ringing in the lower print with input shaper enabled. Upper print is without input shaper. Both are done with 1500mms accleration increasing each 5mm up to 7000mm/s accleration and the print speed is 100mm/s.
-
@minim said in Anybody using a Duet board with a Klipper SBC?:
it still shows great improvement of ringing
Improvement is very significant. Does the printer sound quiet or more graceful at high speeds?
-
@minim take a look at fluidd - it's excellent.
-
@zapta yeah it does actually. I don’t think I will switch back even if I hate SBC
